[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]
>>Yes, because both Stegosaurus stenops and the smaller plated
>>armatus occur in the same fossil deposits (e.g. Marsh-Felch Qaurry).
>>Also, the paleoenvironment of the Chinese sites are similar to that of
>>the Morrison Formation - i.e. semi-arid, seasonal rain fall. Therefore
>>the thermo regime was similar for the various stegosaurs.
>>The vascularized plates simply mean that abundant blood was available
>>the plates and would allow them to "blush" in display.
>Thank you for the clarification.
>"Blushing" in display is of course well known for some birds with areas
>vascularized bare skin (honeyeaters of the genus Melipotes come to
>However, I am still not entirely convinced. Even if the primary
>the plates was display, their vascularization would surely have caused
>to have, at least passively, some thermoregulatory effect (indeed I am
>sure how S. stenops could have avoided this unless there was some
>complicated shunting mechanism involved). Further, African elephants
>occupy an extremely wide range of thermal regimes) use their ears both
>display and thermoregulation, despite the fact that Asian elephants
>much smaller ears (in fact a palaeospecies of Elephas coexisted with
>Loxodonta africana at Olduvai, though of course we don't know how big
>ears were). Is it at least possible that there were behavioural
>among sympatric stegosaurids that may have had thermoregulatory
>Ronald I. Orenstein Phone: (905) 820-7886
>International Wildlife Coalition Fax/Modem: (905) 569-0116
>Home: 1825 Shady Creek Court Messages: (416) 368-4661
>Mississauga, Ontario, Canada L5L 3W2 Internet:
>Office: 130 Adelaide Street W., Suite 1940 Compuserve ID: 72037,2513
>Toronto, Ontario Canada M5H 3P5
I am not against the plates having a secondary role for
thermoregulation. Having that large of a surface area makes it
inevitable. However, considering the diversity of plate size and shapes
among stegosaurs, I argue that the major role was species recognition or
display (threat or sexual). Considering that the two species of North
American Stegosaurus' co-occur in Colorado (e.g. Marsh-Felch) and
Wyoming (e.g. Quarry 13, Como Bluffs) they were both subjected to the
same climatic conditions. Yes, I do think that there was behavioral
separation of the two species, but this does not necessarily imply
living in different habitats.
You seem to disagree with my hypothesis. What is your's? You hint at
something in your last sentence but do not elaborate.