[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]
Re: Supernova/mass extinction business
On Thu, 19 Jan 1995 firstname.lastname@example.org wrote:
> Okay, I can dig that - but we know the motions of all the stars
> in our vicinity, and a star some 35 lightyears from us that went
> nova _would_ leave a black hole, pulsar or white dwarf whose proper
> motion could be backtracked to that point.
I'd like to know how. I think you are making a few non-valid
assumtions, like that the orbit was nearly identical to the suns.
Certainly few, if any, of the stars within 35 lightyears are identical.
We simply have no idea which stars were with-in 35 lightyears 250m years
ago (well they probibly know a few).
> A relative motion of, say, 10 miles
> per second should still place the object within a sphere of around
> 2500 ly. There's a lot of stars in that sphere, but the number of
> nova remnants isn't very large. Backtracking motion to a ring around
> the Earth where such destruction must have originated cannot be that
The problem here is that we can see only a part of the galaxy, a
large part is completely blocked by dust, gas, etc
Of course a super-nova is speculation, but to dismiss it because we
don't know where the remnant is, right now, is a little premature.
Ralph Lindberg N7BSN Ellen Winnie N7PYK e-mail => email@example.com (best
address, mail forwards to find us) firstname.lastname@example.org
email@example.com (other addresses)
firstname.lastname@example.org (last resort only)