[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]


Timothy Williams wrote:

<But, as I said previously, discovering a single 
coelophysoid-like tooth near a postcranium (even if
that postcranium is coelophysoid) is no 100% guarantee
that the two come from the same animal. Remember those
teratosaurids - carnivore teeth associated with
prosauropod postcrania.>

  Yes, but I'm also reminded of the holotype and
referred material for *Probactrosaurus
mazongshanensis* is a cranium and various postcranial
element (respectively) which are associated, but not
articulated [which is why they aren't paratypes]. But
the morphology is congruent between the two,
suggesting homogeneity of the elements.

<I'd bet the tooth does belong to _Gojirasaurus_, but
only further discoveries will settle the matter for

  As much as you could say the likelyhood of two
larger, similar-sized coelophysoids in the same
formation and quarry, but distinct forms, is less
parsimonious and less-likely than to suggest they are
the same form. A tooth of a coelophysoid associated
with the skeleton of a coelophysoid much larger than
any requisite element of *Shuvosaurus* shows that in
any form, there is _one_ coelophysoid. This is the
process, I believe, that Carpenter (1997) used to
suggest homogeneity. I do understand what you're
saying, and would essentially agree; but, if it was
possible the two forms might not be congruent (the
tooth would be either plesiomorphic, or with some
mosaic/chamaeric tendencies) I would agree even more
to not refer the tooth to *Gojirasaurus* until future
discoveries may confirm it. This has been done with
all those tooth-bearing *Megalosaurus* species, the
*Carcharodontosaurus saharicus* case being a prime one
of how the association is wrong [well, for a _lot_ of
reasons]; same for *Dilophosaurus* until the
distinctive and basal form of the elements was uncovered.

Jaime "James" A. Headden

  Dinosaurs are horrible, terrible creatures! Even the
  fluffy ones, the snuggle-up-at-night-with ones. You think
  they're fun and sweet, but watch out for that stray tail
  spike! Down, gaston, down, boy! No, not on top of Momma!

Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail - Free email you can access from anywhere!