[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]


My first book came out today. Is...

Martill, D. and Naish, D. 2000. _Walking With Dinosaurs The 
Evidence_. BBC (London), ISBN 0-780563-537434.

While Dave is first author, he certainly did not do the majority of the 
writing. The BBC insisted that he be first author because he was a 
consultant for the series (another illustration of the way the media 
works). This reminds me of the 'ARTHUR C. CLARKE' books about 
world mysteries - Clarke's name is in massive writing but he never 
wrote the books - the small print reveals Welfare and Fairley down at 
the bottom. Anyway, overall the book is Ok and quite attractive - there 
are a few mishaps introduced by last minute editing (e.g. 'it is a mystery 
why ichthyosaurs did not survive the end of the Cretaceous', rather 
than 'it is a mystery why ichthyosaurs did not survive TO the end of the 
Cretaceous'). Everything written about temnospondyls is total junk - 
what we say about the life habits and affinities of _Koolasuchus_ is 
either outdated or just plain wrong. Of course I learnt all this (via 
Adam) once the book had gone to press. Oh well.

We do discuss some stuff not normally covered in your average 
popular dinosaur book. Feathers on small theropods are championed 
(despite the scaly small theropods that featured in WWD), secondary 
flightlessness for some theropods is discussed, the idea of pack hunting 
dromaeosaurs is critiqued. _Deinosuchus_ is an alligator (in the series 
it was a crocodile), the distribution of heat-sensitive pits in snakes is 
discussed, and there is a detailed discussion about the size of 
_Liopleurodon_. We note that _Dendrorhynchoides_ seems to be an 
anurognathid and that _Muttaburusaurus_ is not an iguanodontid. Late 
Cretaceous provincalism and _Ausktribosphenos_ are covered (the 
idea that _Ausktribosphenos_ is a hedgehog was not published until 
after submission, so this does not get a mention, nor do we mention 
the eupantothere _Teinolophos trusleri_). Obviously there is a lot of 
text on the main characters of the series - _Postosuchus_, 
_Coelophysis_, _Cryptoclidus_, _Eustreptospondylus_, 
_Stegosaurus_, _Diplodocus_, _Tyrannosaurus_ etc etc etc.

_Name dropping_

Obviously all the series consultants get a mention in the introduction. 
However, wherever possible we mention people when they have done 
work which contributed to the outcome of the series. Among those we 
pay homage to are Sankar Chatterjee (_Postosuchus_), Gillian King 
(dicynodonts), Hans Sues (dicynodonts), Robert Reisz (dicynodonts), 
Willem Hillenius (RTs), Dan Chure (Aussie 'allosaur'), Charles 
Deeming (ichthyosaur embryos), Walter Coombs (swimming 
dinosaurs and ankylosaurs), Mike Taylor (gastroliths), Dino Frey 
(pterosaurs and sexing theropods), Tom Rich and Patricia Vickers-
Rich (_Leaellynasaura_ and K polar climate) Chris Brochu (work on 
Sue), Nessov, Osborn, Molnar, Czerkas, Erickson, Brett-Surman, 
Flannery, Myhrvold and Currie, Riggs, Alexander, Lockley, Dodson, 
Wellnhofer, Kirkland, Welles.... even Bakker.

Right now we're trying (unsuccessfully) to arrange publicity. I'm 
dreading the reviews.

School of Earth, Environmental & Physical Sciences
Burnaby Building
Burnaby Road                           email: darren.naish@port.ac.uk
Portsmouth UK                          tel: 01703 446718
P01 3QL