[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

Re: Megaraptor Claw

Steven Coombs wrote:

> the only material found of Megaraptor was the 
> famous "Sickle Claw", Ulna, and Finger and you can`t
> forget the "Metatarsal", But when you have all this
> material more associated with the forelimb why do 
> they say the Metatarsal and go right away that the 
> claw was bipedal?. And you  really only have a 
> Metatarsal. But you do not have Phalanges(Toe), but
> the finger bones which are Phalanges also. Could the
> Metatarsal be the "Metacarpals"? Than you would have
> an almost complete part of the right side of the 
> forelimb with the ulna bone. 
> Steve

I don't know the exact shape of the ulna, but if it is
posteriorly bowed, that would be a strong indication
of at least maniraptoran affinities. The manual
phalanx is interpreted as I-1. If this is spinosaur
material, then it should be a large easily diagnosed
element -  phalanx length equal to 300% the depth at
its proximal articulation. What would be helpful is if
I knew the morphology of the distal metatarsal III
(anyone care to volunteer some info?). I REALLY doubt
someone would confuse a metacarpal for a metatarsal,
but I suppose it's possible. One last comment on the
claw. I've heard it sheath tracts/grooves  are
asymmetric - just like some other dromaeosaurs. I
don't know if any spinosaurs evolved this
convergently, but i've never heard about it being
present in spinosaur unguals. I think there is a good
case for placing it with dromaeosaurs, but I would
like to hear what HP Mickey Mortimer has to say about
it since he has such a keen interest in these
critters. I'm more of a carnosaur/basal tetanuran

BTW, I got that spinosaur phalanx synapomorphy from
Sereno, where he states "First manual digit length
300% the depth at proximal end." I'm not sure if he
meant the entire digit or the 1st phalanx or
ungual....anyone care to clear that up? thanks

Do You Yahoo!?
Get personalized email addresses from Yahoo! Mail - only $35 
a year!  http://personal.mail.yahoo.com/