[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

Re: Not so new papers

> > This might
> > explain its apparent absence in the Bavarian _Compsognathus_ and its
> > presence in _Sinosauropteryx_ of Liaoning.
> No one knows whether _Compsognathus_ had or had not feathers. The stone
> around the Bavarian specimen has been *POLISHED* so that lithographies of
> the fossil could be made. B-( :.-( Eventual ( = highly probable)
> of protofeathers in that limestone would have been very faint, I think.
> dig up the ref tomorrow.

Here it is:

Adrian J. Desmond: The Hot-Blooded Dinosaurs. A Revolution in Palaeontology,
Blond & Briggs 1975

footnote 32 to chapter 6:

"Ostrom, J. H., >>Reply to >Dinosaurs as Reptiles<<<, _Evolution_ (1974),
28, pp. 491 -- 493. _Compsognathus_, also found in the Solnhofen sediments,
was small itself, though bigger than _Archaeopteryx_. It is imaginable that
this coelurosaur bore feathers. According to Ostrom (pers. comm. 4 March
1974) the slab that contains _Compsognathus_ has been polished smooth around
the fossil, by which action eventually present faint feather impressions
would have been destroyed. _Compsognathus_ was discovered _before_ the first
(the London) specimen of _Archaeopteryx_, so that at the time of its
discovery nobody had looked for eventual plumage. In the last three
[remember, 1975] _Archaeopteryx_ specimens the feather impressions are so
weak that the fossils were at first not recognized as Urvogel remains.

!! my retranslation from German, the original wording must be different !!

HP Dan Bensen wrote:

> I thought the reason we didn't see fuzz on Compsognathus is because the
> sandstone didn't preserve dinofuzz as well as the shale(?) at Liaoning.

Entirely possible, no one says any impressions were present around
_Compsognathus_ before polishing. One or two new small theropods have been
found there in the last few years, let's have a close look at them when they
are :.-( published...
        Oh, it's not sandstone, it is plated limestone which looks a lot
like shale (apart from color).