[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]
I would definitely not spell raptor with a capital "R" in the middle of
sentence as though it was a formal taxon. Even avian raptors would form a
polyphyletic taxon, since the owls are not closely related to (i.e., in an
exclusive clade with) hawks or other raptors.
It's a term like swimmer or scansor, although raptors aren't nearly as
numerous as other such categories of animals (which is to be expected since
raptors are predators and at or near the top end of food chains).
Only formal evolutionary classifications should have formal capitalized
names, and names which are based on ecology, body form, life habits, etc.,
should be informal (and raptor is clearly one of the latter). Jurassic Park
has popularized and permanently widened the use of raptor to include the
coelurosaur-type raptors, and there were some large predatory ground birds
in the Cenozoic that might be included in that category as well. I see no
problem with this, but I would object if I saw something formal like Class
"Raptora". Likewise I have no problem with an informal "classification"
like "worms", but a Phylum "Vermes" or "Worms" is definitely a huge no-no.
---- My two cents worth, Ken
From: Dinosaur Interplanetary Gazette <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Subject: Re: Raptor
Date: Fri, 22 Jun 2001 19:46:26 -0400
Out of curiousity, have we all finally arrived at some "stasis" (or is it
"resignation") that the term Raptor is now indelibly established as a
scientific term that includes Velociraptors, Utahraptors, etc. etc.?
Let me note that an inquiry to Discovery Channel about their use of the
assures me that several respectable and notable paleontologists (yes, I
their names. no, I'm not going to say who because it's not important) think
just fine and that "Raptor" is a legit classification.
This is meant as a legit question. Rephrased:
"Has the paleontology community "formally" adopted the term "Raptor" to
a certain class of dinosaurs in the face of overwhelming popular usage of
term? Or is the 'raptors' are birds like hawks' argument still firmly in
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Dinosaur Interplanetary Gazette - Science, Wisdom, Stupid Jokes
Honored by National Education Association, Encyclopedia Britannica Internet
Guide, Yahoo and Yahooligans Choice, Netscape Site of the Day. Member of
Bear Bob's Story - The secret history of Theodore Roosevelt ...
A prequel to Teefr by Edward Summer
A Yahooligans choice.
Laser Publications, Planetarium Station, Box 502-DIG, NY, NY 10024-0502
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com
- Re: raptor
- From: Dinosaur Interplanetary Gazette <email@example.com>