From: firstname.lastname@example.org [mailto:email@example.com]On Behalf Of Henri Rönkkö
And then, I would like to know if these "clavicles" from Oviraptor and the theropod Camp found (it would also be nice to know what theropod this was) were real furculas or just usual clavicles. I believe clavicles are primitive character of Tetanurans.
Actually, Tykowski's disseration on Syntarsus describes the presence of a furcula in that form, and probable Coelophysis furculae have been identified by Downs. This, combined with the fact that the Carnotaurus clavicle element is damaged and the symphsis is not accessible strongly supports the idea that furculae, rather than unpaired clavicles, are the basal condition for Neotheropoda (ceratosaurs plus tetanurines).
Thomas R. Holtz,