[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]
"Dewey M. McLean" <firstname.lastname@example.org> writes:
> First, please allow me to correct your: "since you seem to believe
> that multiple iridium layers *always* means multiple iridium
> Here is my response to David Marjanovic on Thu, 08 Jan 2004
> "I prefer to think of individual spikes in place.
Then that is not a "correction". You are actually agreeing with my
interpretation of your views. ;-)
> The record demonstrates that I stated my opinion 10 days ago.
The timing of these published opinions matters little to me (I also don't
care who first published them). It's more important that they are
> You stated: "it makes no difference to me what the opinions of the
> various authors were."
> In fact, one of the authors of the "Sequence
> stratigraphic setting of the Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary in central
> Alabama Bragg, Alabama" paper--that I have referenced several times
> as having three iridium spikes--is the world-renowned Peter Vail,
> father of sequence stratigraphy.
"Milton Krogman, the foremost expert on the human skeleton in foresic
science". (Sorry, I couldn't resist! This is an inside joke from Usenet
that only a mercifully few list members will understand. But I digress).
To *describe* a section of strata doesn't not necessarily mean that the
describer *understands* what he is describing! ;-) Keep in mind that,
prior to the discovery of the K-T iridium layer, stratigraphers didn't
have ANY experience working with world-wide chron-layers. This means
that, prior to Alvarez et al.'s first paper, Dr. Vail had no experience
with the subject. This is not an indictment of Vail, it's just a
I should point out that A. S. Romer, father of modern vertebrate
paleontology, has had more than a few of his own ideas disproven over the
years. Possessing name recognition doesn't mean that one is not
vulnerable to having one's ideas falsified.
> Incidentally, two of my former graduate students worked with members
> of the Vail team while they were at Exxon.
I think I will let my participation in this thread die a merciful death.
My view of the K-T debate is that it shouldn't be about individual
personalities, nor should it rely on name-dropping for support. Instead,
it should be about the science.
The best thing to hit the internet in years - Juno SpeedBand!
Surf the web up to FIVE TIMES FASTER!
Only $14.95/ month - visit www.juno.com to sign up today!