[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

RE: Purple Paleo Prose Down Under

Tim Williams wrote:

> The 'Demon Duck of Doom' label also appears to be a reference to the 
> putative anseriform affinities of dromornithids.   I suspect that it's
> a way of emphasizing that dromornithids are NOT ratites, despite the
> that they were large terrestrial flightless birds.  However, modern 
> Anseriformes contain more than just ducks, geese, and swans - this
> also includes the screamers, which are less familiar to most people.
> researchers that put dromornithids in the Anseriformes also regard the

> screamers (Anhimidae) as being closest (both phylogenetically and 
> ecologically) to dromornithids.  Screamers are found only in South
> but I have also been told that there is evidence that the modern 
> magpie-goose (_Anseranas_) of Australia may be more closely related to
> screamers than to the Anatidae (ducks, geese, swans).

    To clarify: In the DNA-DNA hybridisation studies of Sibley et al.
that where conducted in the 1980s, _Anseranas_ appeared closer to
screamers than other Anatidae s.l. DNA-DNA hybridisation is intended to
measure the overall similarity of the DNA from different taxa, and is a
fairly rough and ready method of looking at relationships (being
essentially a phenetic distance method). It's cheap, it can give you an
idea of promising directions to look in, but it's probably not very
reliable in the long run*. In all the studies I've seen more recently
(both morphological and better molecular methods), _Anseranas_ has
returned to its position as next basalmost living anseriform after
screamers. Still, _Anseranas_ is a lot more reminiscent of a screamer
ecologically than any other Anatidae s.l.
    In relation to dromornithids, analogy with other living anseriforms/
Galloanserae would suggest a largely omnivorous diet - primarily
vegetable matter, but a reasonable amount of animal food where


        Christopher Taylor

*My comments on the unreliability of DNA-DNA hybridisation are in no way
a condemnation of Sibley et al. for using them. Molecular methods of
looking at relationships were still in a very primitive state, and
hybridisation was probably just as good as any other technique available
at the time.

No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.1.394 / Virus Database: 268.10.1/389 - Release Date: