[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

Re: PDF request

Here in Sweden photocopying for private use is fortunately still legal. However, after extended lobbying by publishers photocopying of "entire books" was recently prohibited. A University library I use (no names!) put up a big sign by their photocopier proclaiming the new rule. However, as a precautionary measure, they also moved the photocopier out of sight of the librarian.

Tommy Tyrberg

At 17:51 2007-08-30, franklin e. bliss wrote:
When I was a graduate student in Oxford (Miami University at Oxford
Ohio but just Oxford always sounds more impressive for some
reason :-)) back in the middle ages, everybody made photo copies.  In
fact the library had a long row of machines taking 5 cents a copy so
a roll of nickels was a premium possession.  The library had some
silly policy that actually being able to read articles at your
leisure comfortable in your own chair made for a better learning
environment.  I don't know why they were so brazenly contrary to the
copyright laws.  Something about fair use or some silly thing like
that.  I spent whole days in the library to begin with, imagine all
the extra time it would have taken to read the stuff there to.  I
would have been accused of animal neglect leaving my dog locked in my
house for weeks at a time.
Frank (Rooster) Bliss
MS Biostratigraphy (apparently gained with access to illegally
obtained intellectual property)
Weston, Wyoming

On Aug 30, 2007, at 2:32 AM, K and T Dykes wrote:

<<But anyone can go to a library and make a photo-copy for their
own use
(fair use).>>

I'm a bit late (holidays), but that's not actually always the case,
Some libraries don't allow photocopying of papers on the grounds, I
of possible infringement of copryright.  Whatever the reason might
be, not all allow it.  Out of the kindness of their heart, a
student tried
to photocopy a paper from their university library for me.  Their
straightforward request was met with shocked eyebrows and a shaking
from the librarian, even after the addition of a pretty please.
They were
sent to the corner of the room and instructed to take notes.

Ever so kindly, they did just that and sent those instead.