[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

Re: Dollodon status questioned



Rescued from truncation:

 From McDonald's (2011) abstract...

"Firsthand examination of the holotypes of the two taxa and numerous other =
basal iguanodont specimens=2C as well as a principal components analysis of=
  basal iguanodont dentaries=2C did not find any morphological features to j=
ustify the distinction of Dollodon from Mantellisaurus. Dollodon bampingi i=
s thus best considered a nomen dubium and junior synonym of Mantellisaurus =
atherfieldensis."

I have no opinion of the validity of Dollodon=2C but people have to learn w=
hat nomen dubium means.  Dollodon can be a junior synonym of Mantellisaurus=
  or it can be a nomen dubium=2C but it can't be both.
/rant

Mickey Mortimer

To spell it out, "nomen dubium" means "indistinguishable from two or more species that are distinguishable from each other". If *Dollodon bampingi* is indistinguishable only from *Mantellisaurus atherfieldensis*, it is not a nomen dubium.