[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

Re: Feduccia (mis)quotes me and mentions the DML in his new book

Not terribly scientific, but some of Olson's comments 
are pretty funny.

I too experience a gag reflex whenever i hear birds 
referred to as dinosaurs, even if birds really are 
descended from dromaeosaurs (or whatever), which 
appears to be the case. "Ooh, look at all the little 
dinosaurs out in the birdbath." 

--- On Tue, 1/3/12, Tim Williams <tijawi@gmail.com> wrote:

> From: Tim Williams <tijawi@gmail.com>
> Subject: Re: Feduccia (mis)quotes me and mentions the DML in his new book
> To: dinosaur@usc.edu
> Date: Tuesday, January 3, 2012, 10:41 PM
> Mickey Mortimer <mickey_mortimer111@msn.com>
> wrote:
> > Thought you all might find this interesting...
> >
> > http://theropoddatabase.blogspot.com/2012/01/almost-famous-im-misquoted-in-feduccias.html
> Irrespective of who said what, it's actually very unfair to
> mine a
> mailing list like the DML for comments in order to
> characterize an
> entire body of scientific study, given that the DML
> actively
> encourages (as it should) opinions and contributions from
> amateurs.
> Feduccia's editorial is also hypocritical, given that his
> stablemate
> Storrs Olson is on the record (in a published journal)
> using highly
> charged language to define his scientific opponents. 
> The weaker the
> science, the more contentious and vitriolic its adherents,
> indeed.
> The following are lines from Olson's review of 'New
> Perspectives on
> the Origin and Early Evolution of Birds. Proceedings of
> the
> International  Symposium in Honor of John H. Ostrom'.
> The Auk: 119:
> 1202-1205.  The article not only features quite a few
> personal barbs,
> but also includes an imputation of outright fraud by
> paleontologists:
> "One of the rituals of the Birds-Are-Dinosaurs-Movement
> (BADM) is to
> hold periodic symposia to reaffirm the belief that birds
> really are
> dinosaurs, much as Southern Baptists hold revival
> meetings."
> "Kevin Padian, the Elmer Gantry of the theropod crusade, is
> an author
> on no fewer than four contributions, which does nothing
> tract from
> the Kingdom Hall of Hennig's Witnesses."
> "Having to suppress one's gag reflex as early as page 3,
> where we read
> about 'the considerably more lively varieties [of
> dinosaurs] flitting
> about our backyards,' only generates queasiness for
> tackling what
> follows."
> "The whole underpinning of the BADM is cladism, a
> systematic
> formulation elevated to a religion years ago and with
> adherents as
> fervent as any biblical zealot."
> "None of this 'dino-fuzz' exhibits the structure of a
> pennaceous
> feather. Furthermore, there reportedly are in the same
> deposits
> various other organisms, unrelated to birds or theropods,
> that sport
> those same filaments. If so, the information has been
> suppressed."
> "Prum's own essay is little more than naked proselytizing,
> designed to
> cajole the heathen onto the path of enlightenment."