[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

RE: Giant Saurophaganax humerus?

That's 14 years ago, but what I think I did was use the scale bar in Chure 
(1995; fig. 2), which results in a length of ~545 mm.  Then I determined this 
was 1.76 times the size of Allosaurus' proposed neotype USNM 4734, which was 
listed in Paul (1988) as 7.4 meters long.  1.76 times 7.4 m is 13 m.  

As that was almost half my life ago, I've become a bit wiser since then.  Maybe 
the scale bar is wrong, in which case the humerus wasn't so long.  Instead of 
being 51% of the femur, 485 mm would be 46%.  Three Allosaurus specimens with 
reported lengths have ratios of 39-43%, so that would be closer.  Or maybe 
(that) Saurophaganax just had longer arms than (measured) Allosaurus.  Finally, 
it should be noted that most of USNM 4734's tail is missing, and specimens with 
more complete tails haven't been described or measured in the literature, so 
Paul's allosaurid length measurement might be inaccurate.

Mickey Mortimer

> Date: Sat, 30 May 2015 14:02:05 +0200
> From: dariusnau@gmx.at
> To: dinosaur@usc.edu
> Subject: Giant Saurophaganax humerus?
> An older topic mentions a humerus of Saurophaganax maximus indicating a
> length of 13m: http://dml.cmnh.org/2001Jan/msg00445.html
> The specimen can only be OMNH 1935, given in the Theropod Database to be
> 545mm long (consistent with the estimated total length).
> I couldn’t find anything explicit on the size of that element in
> published works that describe Saurophaganax material (Chure 1995 and
> 2000), does anyone here know what it based on and whether it is accurate?
> By contrast, Smith 1998 contains an unspecified Saurophaganax humerus in
> a plot (Figure 18), where its length is given as about 485mm. However
> that study is cited in the post I’m referring to, so Mortimer is
> probably aware of that.
> What am I overlooking?
> ---References:
> Chure, Daniel J. (1995): A Reassessment of the gigantic Theropod
> Saurophagus maximus from the Morrison Formation (Upper Jurassic) of
> Oklahoma, USA. In: Sun, Ailing; Wang Yuan

> Mesozoic terrestrial Ecosystems and Biota, Short Papers. Beijing.
> pp. 103-106
> Chure, Daniel J. (2000): A new Species of Allosaurus from the Morrison
> Formation of Dinosaur National Monument (Ut-Co) and a revision of the
> theropod Family Allosauridae. New York
> Smith, David K. (1998): A Morphometric Analysis of Allosaurus. Journal
> of Vertebrate Paleontology, Vol. 18 (1) pp. 126-142
> Darius Nau
> --
> dariusnau@gmx.at
> http://www.paleo.keepfree.de