[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

[dinosaur] Deccan Traps dating, extent

Ben Creisler

Some recent papers about the Deccan Traps


Isabel M. Fendley, Courtney J. Sprain, Paul R. Renne, Ignacio Arenillas, Josà A. Arz, Vicente Gilabert, Stephen Self, LoÃc Vanderkluysen, Kanchan Pande, Jan Smit & Tushar Mittal (2020)
No CretaceousâPaleogene Boundary in Exposed Rajahmundry Traps: A Refined Chronology of the Longest Deccan Lava Flows From 40Ar/39Ar Dates, Magnetostratigraphy, and Biostratigraphy.
Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems (advance online publication)
doi: https://doi.org/10.1029/2020GC009149


Deccan Traps flood basalt volcanism affected ecosystems spanning the endâCretaceous mass extinction, with the most significant environmental effects hypothesized to be a consequence of the largest eruptions. The Rajahmundry Traps are the farthest exposures (~1000 km) of Deccan basalt from the putative eruptive centers in the Western Ghats, and hence represent some of the largest volume Deccan eruptions. Although the three subaerial Rajahmundry lava flows have been geochemically correlated to the Wai Subgroup of the Deccan Traps, poor precision associated with previous radioisotopic age constraints has prevented detailed comparison with potential climate effects. In this study, we use new 40Ar/39Ar dates, paleomagnetic and volcanological analyses, and biostratigraphic constraints for the Rajahmundry lava flows to ascertain the timing and style of their emplacement. We find that the lower and middle flows (65.92Â0.25 and 65.67Â0.08 Ma, Â1Ï systematic uncertainty) were erupted within magnetochron C29r and were a part of the Ambenali Formation of the Deccan Traps. By contrast, the uppermost flow (65.27Â0.08 Ma) was erupted in C29n as part of the Mahabaleshwar Formation. Given these age constraints, the Rajahmundry flows were not involved in the endâCretaceous extinction as previously hypothesized. To determine whether the emplacement of the Rajahmundry flows could have affected global climate, we estimated their eruptive CO2 release and corresponding climate change using scalings from the LOSCAR carbon cycle model. We find that the eruptive gas emissions of these flows were insufficient to directly cause multiâdegree warming, hence a causal relationship with significant climate warming requires additional Earth system feedbacks.

Plain Language Summary

Flood basalt eruptions are among the largest volcanic eruptions in Earthâs history and are frequently associated with mass extinctions. The Deccan Traps flood basalt erupted close in time to the endâCretaceous mass extinction, which marked the demise of the dinosaurs. We determine the timing of the largest known Deccan eruptions, the Rajahmundry Traps, which are potentially the longest lava flows in the world. These eruptions were thought to have played a role in the mass extinction. We estimate when these eruptions happened using techniques including 40Ar/39Ar radioisotopic dating, paleomagnetism, micropaleontology, and geochemistry. We find that the Rajahmundry Traps erupted after the mass extinction. Additionally, we find that the eruptions happened around the same time interval as climate warming which may have impacted the ecological recovery after the mass extinction. We model the climate effects of the Rajahmundry eruptions and find that their eruptive CO2 emissions were likely not enough to directly cause multiâdegree warming. However, volcanic systems may nonâeruptively emit CO2 or may cause other environmental effects which could indirectly increase the amount of climate warming.

Key Points

Exposed Rajahmundry Traps lava flows were all erupted after the CretaceousâPaleogene boundary, between 65.92 and 65.27 million years ago
Rajahmundry Traps consistent with Deccan Traps chronoâ and chemostratigraphy, thus are very long flows from main Deccan eruptive vents
Model and climate records show that eruptive CO2 release from large individual Deccan eruptions is insufficient to cause significant warming


P. Krishnamurthy Â(2020)
Part 1: Areal extent and distribution, compositional diversity, flow types and sequences, stratigraphic correlations, dyke swarms and sills, petrography and mineralogy.
Journal of the Geological Society of India 96: 9-35
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12594-020-1501-5

The Deccan Volcanic Province (DVP), covering presently an area of 0.5 million km2, and estimated to be 2-3 times larger during the Upper Cretaceous-Paleocene, is one of the largest continental flood basalt provinces of the world. Its formation has been linked to the foundering of the Gondwanaland and Greater Indiaâs northward drift, passing over the Reunion plume and eruption of over a million km3 of lava that apparently led to a mass extinction of global proportions. The DVP has thus been a major domain of scientific interest and study the world over. It had received attention since the 1830s, first from the army and civil service men of the British Raj and subsequently from the officers of the Geological Survey of India (GSI) founded in 1851, and academicians from a number of Indian Universities and research Institutions, often in collaboration with geologists from countries such as the UK, USA, Russia, France, Japan, Italy and others. Thus, studies of the DVP conducted for over 170 years, and especially in the last five decades, have provided a very large database that has led to a better understanding of the genesis and evolution of the this province and similar flood basalt provinces of the world.

The DVP is thickest in the Western Ghats, forming many individual 400 m to 1650 m thick sections over some 700 km. The structural evolution of the lava sequence envisages a pre-uplift, thick (c. 2â3 km), lensoid pile of dense basalt that gradually sank into the crust by the end of the eruptive phase, followed by an uplift of the western margin of the Deccan due to both denudational-isostasy reasons and the associated geomorphological and structural evolution of the lava pile from Tertiary uplift and coastal flexure formation (the Panvel structure). Such an evolution has led to stresses that get accommodated along fractures in the pre-Deccan basement at varying depths and apparently provide the loci for seismicity observed over the province. The DVP is predominantly composed of quartz- and hypersthene-normative tholeiitic basalts in the plateau regions (Western Ghats and adjoining central and eastern parts, Malwa and Mandla). However, along the ENE-WSW-trending Narmada-Tapi rift zones, the N-S to NNW-SSE-trending Western coastal tract, the Cambay rift zone, and the Saurashtra and Kutch regions, the DVP shows considerable diversity in terms of structures, dyke swarms and dyke clusters, and intrusive and extrusive centres with diverse rock types. These include: primary picrite basalts and their differentiates (e.g., Botad, Dhandhuka, Wadhwan Jn., Pavagadh), granophyre-rhyolite intrusive ring-complexes and mixed basalt-rhyolite associations (e.g., Alech, Barda, Osham, Chogat-Chamardi, Mumbai Island, and others), carbonatite-nephelinite associations (Amba Dongar-Kawant), gabbro-anorthosite-nepheline syenite-syenite ring/layered complexes(e.g., Mt. Girnar, Mundwara, Phenai Mata), mantle-derived spinel peridotite-hosting melanephelinites and basanites (e.g. Dhrubya, Vethon and others in Kutch), besides scores of alkaline and lamprophyre dykes. Some of these complexes are associated with high gravity anomalies indicating dense plutonic bodies at depths.

Flow morphological studies of the DVP have led to the recognition of two main types of flows, namely âaâa (typically forming simple, sheet flows) and pÃhoehoe (typically forming compound, pahoehoe lobate flows) with transitions between them that result in mixed types. The âaâa types are largely single units found in the peripheral parts where thicknesses of the flow sequence range from a few meters to a few tens of meters. The compound pÃhoehoe flows contain many units or lobes and are largely found in the thicker sections of Western Ghats, and also in the central parts of the province. The flow sequences of the Western Ghats (c. 400 m to 1650 m thick and spread over an area of 400 km à 100 km along the N-S tract from north of Nasik to Belgaum) have been mapped and correlated using flow morphology, petrology and selected trace elements (Sr, Ba, Zr, Y and Ti) and Sr- isotopes. Such a combination of geochemical characters, constrained further by altitude and magnetic polarity (chrons 30N-29R-29N) have led to the delineation of the flow sequences from north to south into a Deccan Basalt Group, comprising three Subgroups from the base to the top, namely the Kalsubai, Lonavala and Wai Subgroups, with twelve (12) formations in total, each formation containing many flows. Giant plagioclase basalts (GPBs) and bole beds of diverse origin (intertrappean sediments, weathered basalt or tuffs with baking effects) have been found in many flow sequences of the DVP, especially in the Western Ghats and contiguous plateau regions, and these interflow units help in subregional-scale mapping and also provide insights into magma chamber processes and eruptive breaks in the volcanic cycles.

Field and geochemical studies of some twenty-three (23) flow sequences (10 from Western Ghats, five from central India and eight from eastern India) by several groups have enabled correlation of some formations of the Western Ghats such as the Ambenali (crustally uncontaminated) and Poladpur (contaminated) over long distances (c. 400â700 km) to Toranmal, Mhow, Chikaldara, Jabalpur and other sections. However, these formations occur at different stratigraphie elevations at these places and also differ in some isotopic characters (e.g. 206Pb/204Pb). Such features have cast doubts on long distance travel of flows from a single source and led to suggestions of multiple source areas (vents and dykes) as also inferred from the two zones of compositional diversity mentioned above.

Based on detailed field, petrological and geochemical characters including isotopic data and Ar-Ar ages, dyke swarms and clusters in the Narmada-Tapi and western coastal tracts have been shown to belong to two groups: (1) The randomly oriented group between Pune and Nasik as possible feeders to the lava flow sequences of the Western Ghats and (2) Some of the dykes from the east-west-oriented Narmada-Tapi swarm, attributed to active N-S extension during the flood basalt episode, and showing chemical affinities to the lower and middle formations (Jawhar, Igatpuri, Neral, Thakurwadi, Bhimashankar, Khandala). A wide variety of petrographic types of basalts have been observed in the DVP attesting to the diverse crystallisation and differentiation of the different magma types during transport and in magma chambers. Based on petrographic and mineralogical data from a number of thick sections, it has been inferred that minerals such as olivine (Fo90âFo20), clinopyroxenes (diopsidic augite, augite, subcalcic augite and pigeonite), plagioclase (An84âAn30) and opaque oxides including spinels show considerable variations depending upon the tholeiitic or alkaline character of the host magma and its degree of evolution. Secondary minerals, especially zeolites such as heulandite and stilbite, are found in all the ten formations of the Western Ghats whereas merlionite and analcite are only found in the Khandala Formation. Other ten species are of variable abundance are found in the ten formations of the Western Ghats and other areas. Zeolite zonation in DVP suggested earlier has not been substantiated by recent studies, instead multigeneration of secondary minerals in cavities is attributed to late hydrothermal activity from Paleocene to early Miocene.

Virus-free. www.avg.com